If You’re Lucky Is a Theory of Mine is Matt Mauch’s second full-length collection of poetry, and it just slays me. Mauch has the delivery of a comedian—not Dane Cook, but an actual comedic genius (sorry Cook fans...sort of). The hyper-specificity, the virtuosic phrasing, the ability to relate to nearly anyone on a universal level—it’s all working for him, and doing the quiet work of his poems, which is to say, showing off verbally.
But where there would be ego in the conversational acrobatics of others, Mauch has inserted humility, a thoughtfulness about and for his subjects that doesn’t let up even in poems about, I presume, himself and his experiences. So in a completely different way, he slays me again, with his generosity and big old heart.
His reflections aren’t always cozy. There are funerals, there are “awful years,” there is a keen awareness of mortality. In “From the owner’s manual,” there is fear of becoming “some nobody who believed it when they said / (girls) you were a princess, or that you could grow up // (boys) to be the President of the USA” (p. 43). A poem ending that way can make me so angry with its truth, but then, I flip around and read a title like “Every view is oceanic if you focus on the sky” and think, I can handle that truth from this poet. Mauch is the kind, gracious bearer of bad news who will emotionally clobber you, then take you to a dive bar to fund your co-commiseration.